Interviews

Sara Bakusova: ‘The people who are most wrong often seem the most confident’

Leestijd: 6 minuten

Why is it that people who are completely wrong about something can be so convinced they are right? People like that have long fascinated – and frustrated – Sara Bakusova, winner of the first prize in the KHMW Responsible Internet Thesis Awards 2026. For her master’s thesis in Behavioural Economics at Erasmus University Rotterdam, she investigated whether overconfidence makes people more susceptible to misinformation.

‘I’ve come across so many people who are extremely confident in their views, even when those views are wrong. They’ll stand there arguing with you, explaining why they’re right. I find that incredibly frustrating. And that was really what inspired my research.’

Originally from Slovakia, Sara studied Politics, Economics and Philosophy in Scotland, spent a period as an exchange student in Melbourne, and subsequently moved to Rotterdam. It was during her bachelor’s degree that she discovered behavioural economics, a field combining insights from psychology and economics.

‘Before that, I thought economics was mainly about markets and financial systems. But behavioural economics showed me that you can also study subjects like health and politics through an economic lens.’

For her master’s thesis, she decided to investigate the relationship between overconfidence and susceptibility to misinformation. She chose health misinformation as her focus, partly because health is relevant to people everywhere, regardless of their nationality or political background.

‘Making informed decisions is essential to society’s wellbeing. And health misinformation is particularly consequential, because believing something that isn’t true can have direct physical consequences.’

But how do you investigate whether overconfidence actually causes people to believe misinformation? Sara designed an online experiment in which participants were given questions about health and biology. Some received relatively easy questions, while others were confronted with much harder ones.

The principle behind her experiment was the so-called hard–easy effect, a psychological phenomenon that influences how people assess their own abilities compared with those of others. Sara was particularly interested in overplacement: the tendency to believe that you have performed better than other people.

‘People often fail to realise that if they find a task easy or difficult, other people probably do too. I wanted to use that effect to manipulate their confidence.’

Participants first answered ten general knowledge questions and assessed their performance. They were then randomly assigned either ten easy or ten difficult questions about health. Afterwards, everyone was shown the same ten health-related headlines, some containing misinformation.

The questions were deliberately related to the subjects of the headlines, without providing information that would help participants determine whether the headlines were true or false.

‘The idea was that people who had answered easy questions would feel more confident about their health knowledge. Those who had struggled with difficult questions might begin to doubt their abilities. I wanted to find out whether that difference in confidence would affect their ability to distinguish true information from misinformation.’

Sara expected the participants who had received the difficult questions to be less successful at identifying misinformation. But the results surprised her.

‘We managed to influence people’s confidence levels, but that didn’t translate into a significant difference in their ability to distinguish misinformation from accurate information.’

Rather than seeing this as a failure, she started looking for possible explanations. One of these lies in the difference between temporary confidence and a more deeply rooted sense of confidence in one’s own abilities.

‘My experiment focused on state confidence, which changes depending on the task you’re doing. But everyone also has a certain level of trait confidence, built up over a lifetime of experiences. Perhaps these short-term fluctuations in confidence aren’t what really drives susceptibility to misinformation.’

Her research therefore raises questions about how straightforward the relationship between overconfidence and misinformation actually is. ‘Just because two things are correlated doesn’t mean that one necessarily causes the other.’

Sara’s enthusiasm for analysing data developed during her time in Rotterdam. Her bachelor’s degree had been predominantly qualitative, so the quantitative approach at Erasmus University initially came as a shock.

‘It was incredibly data-heavy, much more than I’d expected. At first I found it really challenging, so I spent a lot of time trying to understand it. But surprisingly, it became my favourite part of the course.’

She compares working with data to solving a puzzle. ‘With qualitative arguments, there isn’t always a clear right or wrong answer. But with data, you know the answers are in there somewhere – you just have to find them. I really enjoy discovering patterns and figuring out how to analyse the data to uncover them.’

Looking back, she is grateful for the support she received at Erasmus University. ‘The university really shaped me as a researcher. My lecturers were always willing to help, and even now I can still turn to them with questions.’

She also looks back fondly on life in Rotterdam. Having lived in several countries, she appreciated the city’s distinctive character.

‘Rotterdam is so different from anywhere else I’ve lived. It’s very modern, and when you move from one neighbourhood to another, it almost feels as though you’re entering a completely different city. I think it’s a perfect place to live in your twenties. There’s always something happening.’

And there was another pleasure she rediscovered in the Netherlands: cycling. ‘I hadn’t cycled since I was a child. It was lovely to start doing that again.’

Sara has since returned to the United Kingdom, where she is exploring career opportunities. She hopes to gain experience through internships in economic consultancy and data analysis. Her long-term ambition is to work for the Behavioural Insights Team (BIT), a UK-based research and consultancy organisation that applies behavioural science to public policy and societal challenges.

‘It’s a competitive field, but I think it’s becoming increasingly important. More consultancy firms are establishing behavioural teams, and governments are becoming more interested in using behavioural insights.’

Would she like to return to the Netherlands one day? ‘Absolutely. I really loved my time there, and I’d love to move back at some point.’

Gerelateerd nieuws